| Steam heating systems, when properly maintained, provide
efficient operation and excellent heating. Understanding how the systems operate and how
the components function is important for proper maintenance. Steam heating systems
generally fall into two categoriesolder one pipe systems and newer two pipe
systems. Some of these are designed to operate under vacuum to speed up the flow of
steam and provide even heating. Vacuum systems should be maintained as vacuum systems
unless they are re-piped and zoned
to provide even heating through the system.
We will limit discussion to the two
pipe systems that have one pipe to deliver steam to the heating units and a second
pipe to drain condensate. They use a steam trap to hold back steam until the latent heat
is removed.
In this configuration, water is heated and converted to steam in the boiler. The steam
leaves the boiler through the distribution pipes. Air in the pipes and heating units must
be vented to allow the steam to enter so steam traps allow the air to discharge into the
return line and to a vented condensate or boiler
feed unit. As the steam gives up its heat, it condenses and the condensate drains
through the steam trap to a condensate pump or boiler feed unit. The most common problem
in these systems is failed steam traps.
The three types of traps generally used in steam heating systems include thermostatic, float and thermostatic, and inverted bucket traps. A failed
steam trap will allow steam to pass into the return line and to the condensate return
units. The high-temperature condensate causes pump cavitation, mechanical seal failure,
energy loss out the vent, and excessive boiler makeup water. A simple check on system
operation is to monitor and record the condensate temperature at the condensate transfer
units. A sudden increase in return temperature indicates that the steam traps require
maintenance.
Thermostatic Trap
Thermostatic steam traps are the most common type found in two pipe steam heating
systems. They are simple in construction and small in size and weight. They have adequate
capacity at the low pressure differentials found in the average steam heating system. Thermostatic traps are the least
expensive traps and are easily serviced.
A thermostatic trap is normally open to quickly discharge air and condensate (water)
during a cold start up. They close in response to temperature as they get close to the
saturation temperature of the steam. Most thermostatic traps close 10 to 30 deg F below
the steam saturation temperature. In a low pressure steam heating system operating at 3
psig, the saturation temperature is 222 F. This means the trap will discharge condensate
somewhere between 212 and 192 F. The return lines in steam heating systems are normally
not insulated; this provides another 20 to 30 deg F subcooling before the condensate
reaches a condensate return pump. The normal condensate temperature at the pump should be
160180 F. This subcooling assures that there is no heat loss due to flash steam
escaping from the receiver vent. It also allows a simple single stage centrifugal
condensate pump to return the condensate.
Float and Thermostatic Traps
Float and thermostatic
(F&T) traps have separate elements for venting air and draining condensate. The
thermostatic element is located above the trap condensate level to allow free air venting
during start up. The thermostatic element is similar to those in thermostatic traps. Air
entering the trap body is discharged through the thermostat seat. The opening and closing
of the thermostat seat depends on the temperature surrounding the thermostatic element.
Initially, condensate fills the trap body to a level slightly above the trap seat. It
is sufficient to seal the valve seat opening, kept closed by the valve pin. As condensate
continues to enter the trap body, the float will rise, causing the valve seat to be
opened. Condensate then will be discharged through the trap outlet. The rise and fall of
the float, due to changes in the water level within the trap body, results in a modulated
discharge which is characteristic of F&T traps.
Inverted bucket traps
Bucket traps are so named because the operating mechanism inside the trap resembles an
upside down open bucket. The bucket is fastened to the end of a lever, and the valve pin
is fastened to the same lever near the fulcrum. A small bleed hole in the top of the
bucket allows air to vent from the bucket.
The bucket trap opens when the bucket is filled with condensate
and lifts to close the trap when it is filled with steam. The bucket trap operation is
open-close; it does not modulate.
Efficient operation
For low pressure steam systems to heat efficiently:
Boilers
should be set for operation at the minimal pressure that will provide the required
heating. Condensate
temperature and resulting flash loss relates to operating pressure.
Most heat
exchangers heating fluids to under 200 F should be sized for 2 psi steam operating
pressure.
Probe boiler
controls should be cleaned or replaced annually.
Float type
boiler controls should be blown down frequently in accordance with the manufacturers
recommendation to prevent the build up of dirt inside the float housing.
Boiler blowdown
should be performed according to the recommendations of the water treatment company.
Use thermostatic
traps where possible to take advantage of subcooling.
Insulate steam
lines to reduce heat loss in the distribution system. Dont insulate the return line
if it results in flash loss or pump cavitation. n Install condensate return units where
condensate is being dumped. Monitor and record condensate temperatures weekly.
Keep traps in
good condition to prevent steam from passing into the return system. Test traps at least
once a year on low pressure systems.
Make sure the
system vents properlyair trapped in the system acts as an insulator and results in
poor heating.
Avoid lifts in
the gravity return lines that can cause poor venting and water
hammer.
This article was originally published in the October 1998 issue of Maintenance
Technology magazine.
Reprinted from TechTalk January 1999 |